same. I was just thinking about this a couple hours ago.
I have hope, though.
same. I was just thinking about this a couple hours ago.
I have hope, though.
As expected some news outlets already published articles on the upcoming decision citing that even the judiciary voiced criticism towards the law.
I expect more to come after the decision since those early reportings cite dpa as their source material which is the largest press agency in Germany offering their sources to be used by others.
somewhat encouraging.
A lot of big news are coming out right now:
“From the perspective of those affected, the ban on child sex dolls has a negative impact on their lives and on the risk of sexual violence against children,” states the conclusion of an article published in the Zeitschrift für Sexualforschung. The available data provided no evidence that the stricter legislation serves to protect children. However, the researchers acknowledge that the study design has limitations in this regard.
Use the build-in translation tool in your browser:
Basically every single newspaper reported on the upcoming decision and they all use the same template from the dpa. I find the template good, because it is very serious and actually mentions that pedophiles are suffering and that the ban is not protecting kids.
Inb4 the actual decision is ass tho.
Well this is the end I guess. The complaints were rejected. Every future pedophile will have to live in absolute hell. I will leave now.
They didn’t rule in favor of the dolls being legal?
They used the typical normie argument of it “normalizes” child abuse and breeds a culture of sex with children.
It was rejected with 6:2. One judge put down a dissenting opinion claiming that the majority opinion is nothing but moral pandering. He cites the laws existence alone violates the most sacred human right of the basic law by essentially invading and regulating how a human masturbates in the privacy of their home.
This is the first paragraph of the dissenting opinion:
I cannot agree with the Senate majority. In my opinion, § 184l of the German Criminal Code is moral legislation without a sufficiently rational basis. The regulation partially interferes with the absolutely protected core area of private living and is therefore unconstitutional for this reason alone (1.). Furthermore, the infringements of fundamental rights originating from it cannot be justified by the considerations of the Senate majority (2.). In my opinion, both of these things result from the consistent application of the standards already developed by the Federal Constitutional Court, which the Senate majority does not --at least not explicitly-- question.
There’s no evidence of this… like at all. I don’t understand how/why people allow themselves to believe this.
I’m actually upset over this. I had high hopes that they would see through this nonsense.
So the majority opinion outright dismissed science in favor of moralism..
is there anything else that can be done? Could a followup appeal be made or reconsideration?
Yep. They also use ICD-10 instead of ICD-11 and claim Pedophilia is an illness (it is not an illness under ICD-11). The dissenting opinion also highlights how they make shit up by listing arguments without giving a source, or what it is based on.
There are now considerations of going to the highest possible level, which would be the European Court of Human Rights. At least there is a dissenting opinion.
I recommend reading the judgement. It is an absolute mess. The dissenting opinion is what would have been worthy.
Here is a google translate link:
They purported to base their decision on science, yet they knowingly cited an obsolete standard..
I’m actually speechless.
I would be angry over this, but I’m so weighed down emotionally by sorrow and depression for German citizens.
This would be like if homosexuality were measured by the US Supreme Court using a version of the DSM that still defined it as a disorder.
They’re killing people with this. They’re killing people who do not deserve to die, forcing them to suffer in silence, and potentially setting the sciences themselves back by disincentivizing them from studying the use of outlets.
Doll owners who are unable to relocate are going to take their own lives.
Majority opinion is unironically citing youtube videos as sources. It is fucking pathetic and the dissenting judge highlights that.
Edit:
Majority Opinion is also citing that dolls are dangerous by invoking a study where 75% of doll owners in the UK also had fictional child pornography. So they undirectly see this also as a concern. How is this an argument against dolls. Wtf? If someone owns a fictional outlet, then he will own another fictional outlet.
Gov. could use trash like this to ban fiction now. Shit is insane.
So in lieu of any actual empirical evidence, they’re relying on testimony by experts and select anecdotes, in addition to UK crime statistics.
How come they don’t question the harm that these legislative actions would have on those affected by these?
Remind me what the age of consent in Germany is? Weren’t there cases involving the enticement and grooming of girls as young as 14 by their adult relatives where courts actually sided with the abuser?
And yes, I was just thinking about that, with respect to bans on fiction.
And It’s always about ‘lowering inhibitions’, yet no evidence exists to support this. The more we study the use of outlets, the more we find that such a function simply does not exist.
What can I say man. They literally bring up that dolls cannot consent:
Because children --unlike adults – cannot effectively consent in the first place to sexual acts with adults, such as those reenacted with sex dolls.
You get judgements like these when the stigma is fucking up in the stratosphere. I am genuinely disappointed.
IT’S A DOLL! The people using these KNOW this! And there is no ‘reenactment’, only fantasy. The conflation of real life concepts with fantastical analogues is a hallmark of an inability to reason.
I can’t believe this is coming from a high court judge in Germany.
I wish I had the privilege of only being disappointed. I’m horrified and scared for people who were banking hard on the ability of reason to prevail.
Yeah, I think most were expecting this, because there is just way too much of a stigma around this. Some German MAP communities have started an emergency support service to prevent suicides by lending them an ear. This judgement will definitely cause suicides regardless.
I actually wasn’t. I legitimately expected them to rule - albeit via slim majority - to find that the complaints had merit and that these particular laws and their underlying rationales were inconsistent with their own legal precedents and were empirically unsound.